Modern Creator
Nate Black · YouTube

THIS Is YouTube's Next Play

An 80-minute live workshop arguing that cheap AI production made originality the new barrier, and that the fix for a stalled channel is one proven thing plus one new thing.

Posted
4 days ago
Duration
Format
Tutorial
educational
Views
8.3K
206 likes
Big Idea

The argument in one line.

Now that tools let anyone produce content, originality is the real barrier on YouTube, and the reliable way to be memorable is to double down on one thing your audience already loves while adding one new thing that feeds it.

Who This Is For

Read if. Skip if.

READ IF YOU ARE…
  • A YouTuber with a few hundred to a few hundred thousand subscribers whose views feel flat and who doesn't know what to focus on next quarter.
  • A creator running a variety channel (gaming plus family plus faith, for example) who sees some videos spike and others die.
  • Someone with one format that clearly works but is too expensive in time to keep making every week.
  • A creator whose audience naturally leaves, like students who stop watching once a class ends or viewers who vanish after a holiday series.
SKIP IF…
  • You want tactical packaging advice on titles and thumbnails. This stream stays at the content-strategy level.
  • You want a tight lecture. Roughly a third of the runtime is live chat check-ins, shout-outs and housekeeping.
TL;DR

The full version, fast.

AI and cheap tools dropped the barrier to making content to its lowest point ever, so production polish no longer separates creators. The new barrier is originality, and YouTube's own policies on mass-produced content back that up. Because every viewer now lives in a personalized 'mini YouTube', the formula is original plus proven equals memorable. Step one: find your one proven thing, a format that beats your other videos, gets requested, or stands out. Step two: add one new thing that you're excited to make and that has a real shot, sourced from audience signals or a similar creator's proven format. New things should feed the proven one, which also offsets natural audience attrition.

Free for members

Chat with this breakdown — free.

Sign in and you get 23 free chat messages on us — ask for the hook, quote a framework, find the exact transcript moment, generate a markdown action plan. Bring your own key when you want unlimited.

Create a free account →
Chapters

Where the time goes.

00:00 – 04:05

01 · Live open and check-in

Chat roll call (location plus last meal), a new early schedule test, and a brief note on a mental-health break from publishing.

04:05 – 08:00

02 · One Proven Thing, One New Thing season

Introduces the season theme and the plan: cover both halves now, roast submitted channels Thursday.

08:00 – 11:35

03 · Why now: the barrier collapsed

Tools dropped the barrier to making content to an all-time low. Great for creators, but it also floods the platform with mass-produced slop.

11:35 – 15:24

04 · The new barrier is originality

Raw to polished to raw again. Cites YouTube Partner Program language and the CEO letter, then the 'mini YouTube' idea and the formula original plus proven equals memorable.

15:24 – 21:47

05 · Part 1: your one proven thing

Three signs a format is proven, the vocal-minority caveat, and a chat exercise: 'My proven thing is... I know because...'

21:47 – 27:15

06 · Workshop: a sports history channel

Scrolling John Lewis Sports to spot the 'Whatever happened to...' series as a proven thread worth doubling down on.

27:15 – 33:54

07 · Workshop: camping to off-grid

Alaskan Nomads shifted from camping to an off-grid cabin build; the off-grid videos now beat camping almost every time, including a near-million-view upload.

33:54 – 38:19

08 · Part 2: your one new thing

A new thing must excite you and have a real shot. Ideas come from audience signals or proof from a similar creator. A new thing is content, not a workflow change.

38:19 – 44:21

09 · Workshop: a decluttering channel

Chat brainstorms new formats for Millennial Meg; her own submission already models adjacent creators' formats like regret purchases and organizing stations.

44:21 – 46:21

10 · Attrition and consistency over outliers

New things counteract natural audience attrition; consistently performing formats can beat chasing outliers.

46:21 – 51:00

11 · Put them together, and the sustainability problem

New things should feed the proven thing. What to do when a proven format is too costly to sustain, and the risk of viral but unsustainable formats.

51:00 – 1:00:14

12 · Thursday roast setup and season recap

Pitch for the group submission form and Thursday's live channel reviews, then a recap of why proven plus new is a multi-way win including sponsorships.

1:00:14 – 1:04:00

13 · Q&A: view counts, collabs, harder subs

The newer view metric inflates numbers; formal collabs work as exposure but aren't a silver bullet; more content means more competition.

1:04:00 – 1:07:09

14 · Q&A: variety channels need common threads

Variety works with common threads or a hero-type personality approach; topic spikes signal missing threads.

1:07:09 – 1:11:30

15 · Q&A: video length and seasonal series

Match length to audience intent; seasonal series work if they aren't your only thread; poll on engaged versus new views.

1:11:30 – 1:19:50

16 · Q&A: finding an audience, class-bound viewers, gaming

No proven thing yet means testing new things modeled on similar creators; adjacent offers for students; gaming success rides on personality or style. Sign-off.

Atomic Insights

Lines worth screenshotting.

  • The barrier to entry for online content is the lowest it has ever been, which makes production quality a weak differentiator.
  • YouTube content has gone full circle: raw early on, then polished, and now back toward authentic and original.
  • Every viewer effectively lives in their own mini YouTube, because the algorithm keeps getting better at showing people what they already like.
  • Original plus proven equals memorable, and memorable is what survives a platform flooded with content.
  • A proven thing shows up in three ways: it beats your other videos, people keep asking for it, or a few videos clearly stand out.
  • A vocal minority of commenters is a data point, but what the silent majority actually watches is the stronger signal.
  • A good new thing passes two checks: you're genuinely excited to make it, and it has a real shot with your audience.
  • The best source of a new format is proof from a similar creator whose audience overlaps yours, adapted to your own spin.
  • A consistently performing format can be worth more than an outlier, because it gives you a predictable baseline.
  • Audience attrition happens to almost every channel, and a steady stream of new formats is how you counteract it.
  • A format that is proven with your audience but unsustainable for you is not really proven; publish it less often and add lower-effort formats that feed it.
  • Variety channels only work when there are common threads that apply to at least 90% of the videos, or when the creator is the draw.
  • If one topic spikes and another gets nothing, the channel is topic-based instead of thread-based.
  • In gaming, the differentiator is never the game. It's the creator.
  • A seasonal series can perform well, but if it's your only thread for a month or two, expect a notable drop-off when the season ends.
  • A live poll of creators put engaged views at roughly 30 to 60 percent of YouTube's newer view count, with 45 percent a common rule of thumb.
Takeaway

Anchor on what works, then add one adjacent thing.

WHAT TO LEARN

When anyone can produce polished content, the edge is being memorable, which comes from doubling down on a format your audience already proves it loves while testing one new format that feeds it.

03Why now: the barrier collapsed
  • Production polish stopped being a moat once tools dropped the barrier to entry, so treat originality as the thing you compete on.
04The new barrier is originality
  • Read the platform's own signals: YouTube's monetization policy explicitly targets mass-produced, generic, repetitive or manipulative content.
  • Because the algorithm serves each viewer a personalized feed of what they already like, aim for original plus proven rather than novelty alone.
05Part 1: your one proven thing
  • Audit your catalog for three proven signals: a format that reliably beats your other uploads, repeated audience requests, or a few clear standouts.
  • Weight what the silent majority actually watches over what the most vocal commenters ask for, in either direction.
06Workshop: a sports history channel
  • A recurring series format, like 'Whatever happened to...' profiles, can be a proven thread hiding in plain sight across scattered uploads.
07Workshop: camping to off-grid
  • When a pivot keeps beating the old format almost every time, as off-grid builds did over camping, that pivot has become your proven thing.
08Part 2: your one new thing
  • Only pick a new format you're genuinely excited about; making something purely because you guess the audience wants it rarely lasts.
  • Source new formats from audience requests or from a similar creator whose overlapping audience already responds to the idea, then adapt it.
  • Count only changes the audience experiences as a new thing; new tools and workflows don't move the audience.
09Workshop: a decluttering channel
  • Model adjacent creators' formats, like regret-purchase lists or organizing guides next to decluttering, to find new things with a real shot.
10Attrition and consistency over outliers
  • Add new formats steadily, because some audience attrition is natural and fresh angles are how you replace those viewers.
  • Prefer a consistently performing format over chasing outliers; predictability is what lets you plan and pitch sponsors.
11Put them together, and the sustainability problem
  • Design each new format so its viewers flow into your proven format instead of becoming a separate audience.
  • If a proven format costs too much to sustain, publish it less often and add lower-effort formats that feed the same audience.
  • Be careful with viral but unsustainable formats, because the audience they attract may not stay for what you can actually keep making.
13Q&A: view counts, collabs, harder subs
  • Formal collabs put you in front of an adjacent audience, but they work through you being engaging, not as a growth shortcut.
14Q&A: variety channels need common threads
  • A variety channel needs common threads covering about 90 percent of videos, or a hero-type creator whose experiences are the draw.
  • If one topic spikes and another flops, the channel is organized by topic rather than by threads the audience recognizes.
15Q&A: video length and seasonal series
  • Set video length by audience intent: deep guides can run 15 to 20 minutes, adventure content tends to sit near ten.
  • Seasonal series can spike engagement, but mix in other threads so the channel doesn't drop off when the season ends.
16Q&A: finding an audience, class-bound viewers, gaming
  • Without any proven thing yet, run a series of new things modeled on similar creators until one earns repeat performance.
  • For audiences with a built-in end point, like students finishing a class, look for the adjacent goal they want next.
  • In gaming, viewers come for a personality or a play style, so being entertaining matters more than which game you choose.
Glossary

Terms worth knowing.

Proven thing
A content format or concept that already performs predictably well with your existing audience, shown by beating other videos, repeat requests, or standout results.
New thing
A new content format or concept the audience will actually experience. Workflow and tool changes don't count in this framework.
Audience attrition
The gradual decline in a channel's active audience as viewers drift away over time, which happens naturally unless the creator keeps giving them fresh reasons to return.
Engaged views
YouTube's stricter view metric shown alongside the newer, more generous view count. It still exists in analytics but takes a few clicks to reach.
Common threads
Shared elements that let a viewer finish the sentence 'I like that channel because...' for nearly every video, which is what holds a variety channel together.
Four creator types
A model of creator approaches: hero, commentator, teacher and performer. The hero type, where the creator has the experience and brings viewers along, handles variety best.
Resources

Things they pointed at.

13:00linkYouTube Partner Program policies (mass-produced, generic, repetitive or manipulative content)
13:00linkYouTube CEO's annual letter ('AI will remain a tool for expression, not a replacement')
22:15channelJohn Lewis Sports
27:39channelAlaskan Nomads
38:19channelMillennial Meg
42:33channelA to Zen Life ('10 Things You Will ALWAYS Regret Buying')
1:07:37link'I found out which video length makes videos explode' (creator's own video)
Quotables

Lines you could clip.

11:35
“The barrier right now is this. Originality. Can you make original content and content that an audience enjoys? It's that. It's as simple as that.”
Clean thesis line, no setup needed→ TikTok hook↗ Tweet quote
13:56
“Original plus proven equals memorable.”
Five-word formula→ newsletter pull-quote↗ Tweet quote
13:28
“Every viewer lives in their own, what I'm calling like a mini YouTube.”
Memorable reframe of the algorithm→ IG reel cold open↗ Tweet quote
46:06
“The best new things feed the proven thing.”
Short rule anyone can apply→ newsletter pull-quote↗ Tweet quote
1:17:55
“The differentiation with gaming creators is not the game, it's the creator.”
Contrarian and quotable for a big niche→ TikTok hook↗ Tweet quote
46:48
“Maybe it's proven with your audience, but it's not something that you can sustain yourself... it's not proven for you.”
Counterintuitive point on burnout formats→ IG reel cold open↗ Tweet quote
The Script

Word for word.

Read-along

Don't just watch it. Burn it in.

See every word as it's spoken — crank it to 2× and still catch all of it. The same dual-channel trick behind Amazon's Kindle + Audible.

metaphorstory
And I think we are live.
Howdy, howdy, everyone. Good morning, or afternoon, or evening, or middle of the night for our dear friends in New Zealand. I would love for you to put in the chat, just welcome, welcome everybody.
Go ahead and put in the chat where you are in the world right now. It's kind of a tradition that we do. I'd just love to hear where you are in the world and the most recent thing you ate.
Kind of gives me a better take on where you are. There we go. Hey, good morning, everybody.
Good morning. You guys are awesome. Good to see you here.
We are about to experience whether or not we had the weirdest pattern change that I have ever done on this channel. There's a whole story behind this, but if you're watching the replay of this, There'll be a bit more context maybe by the time you watch this.
But if you're here live, there's a bit of a change in how I approach the scheduling for this video. So we're about to see if this was like wildly successful or terribly unsuccessful. Kind of feels like there's no in between.
But either way, either way, if there's any in between. on this. If not many people are able to show up to this time, I totally understand.
We're about to have an extremely close -knit live stream. So whoever's here live, by the way, man, you're going to get it. This is the place.
So I see everybody coming in. See chat coming in here. Michigan, hello, hello.
UK, just had lunch. Awesome. Florida and was ice cream.
Man, you get it. You get it. That's the word nerd here.
Millennial Meg from Illinois and ate coffee so far. Vietnam, welcome. Switzerland, a pizza.
Romania, burrito with cheese. Iowa, hello from Toronto. Welcome, everybody.
I am so glad you are here. Genuinely, this is a shift. I'm testing a shift in the schedule.
We're going to try a bunch of stuff with this. But genuinely... I'm glad you are here.
We got someone saying California, WTH. I know it's early. I get it.
I get it. We're testing it. We're testing it.
All right. But if you're just now tuning in, or even if you're watching the replay of this, just put in the comments where you are, as well as the most recent thing you ate. Hey, what's up, Doc?
What's up, Doc? Hey, everyone. So yeah, if you're just now arriving here live, where you are in the world, and the most recent thing you ate.
It's just for fun. All right, I think we're about to do this. Let's jump in here because this is, wow, there's a whole story as to why the long break in publishing.
Maybe we'll have, tell me if you want one of these things. Maybe we'll have some sort of like virtual fireside chat with digital s'mores around a digital campfire sometime and just chat. and wellbeing and all of that.
The short version, I sent an email about this short version is there was a pretty notable mental health things. I'm seeing specialists and things like that. So it is what it is.
I feel like it's a story for another time, but I really, really appreciate everyone who took the time to reach out and check in and see how I was doing, including recommending books and other things. So it was very helpful. It was very helpful.
Thank you. See you more here. UK, awesome soup.
Strawberry yogis. Here we go. Cayuga, Ontario, six raw eggs.
Brazil, peanut butter sandwich. Maryland, apple cider. Berkeley, California, dates with coffee.
Heck yeah. Love that. All right, we're going to do this.
You all ready for this? Going to switch over to this. So a slight shift because I sent out a message.
Here's the premise. I'm creating a theme for this season based on what I have seen. So let me, allow me to zoom in on this graphic I made here.
Calling this one thing, one thing season. There's a big reason why. And originally the plan was to cover, hey, one proven thing this week in this, or sorry, during this life.
And then the one new thing in the next life, after reviewing responses from the For My Full Doubts. I decided we're going to do a workshop, cover both of them right now, and then do some even more roasts in the next live stream. So that's the plan here.
Here's why. Here's the reasoning for this. Everybody buckle up.
If you're driving, please do buckle up. If you're not driving, then do the proverbial buckle up, I guess, because this is going to be pretty impactful, I think, for... uh, many here because this is, it's, it's a big deal what I am seeing right now on YouTube.
So, uh, it's not a, it's, it's, it's not a fake out to say, I think this is YouTube's next play right now. Hence the packaging on this video. Yes.
Okay. So we're jumping in. Mr.
Pegasus, uh, uh, oh nine. What did I miss? We're jumping in.
Uh, it's the, the, the pre -conversation as to what happened and why it's been so long since I published. All right, here we go.
Let's do this. Let me get this to a nice zoom level so you can see everything in one frame. Let's make sure this looks good here.
I'll try to keep it uniform for you. Yeah, there we go. All right, here's what I'm seeing.
The reason why I decided to call this season one thing, one thing, uh, a, the season from now, especially on into the new year is essentially saying, how do we make this coming year? The best year possible, uh, first and foremost for you as creators, but also for YouTube and your audience on the YouTube platform. So, uh, we're, this is what we're covering.
I'm going to spend forever on this. YouTube is abnormally rewarding a certain thing right now. And as well as, we're going to talk about how to spot that one thing on your channel, how to pick one new thing with a real shot, and what to do about it.
What's to do about it? Oh man, you too can live stream. What to do about it?
Yay! Typos, hooray. So, this is what we're doing.
Let's dive in here. Howdy, howdy. A morning surprise of Nate, glad you're here.
I don't know if I'm ready for Christmas, but I'm glad you're here. I'm glad you love this live, Helena Sokana. I hope I pronounced that right.
Yes, I'm glad you're here. Glad you're here. All right.
So let's dive into this. What the heck is going on? Why am I emphasizing one proven thing and one new thing right now?
What is the big deal with this? I apologize if you're on mobile. It's really small right there.
But the focus. Focus, and what is YouTube rewarding right now? So why now?
Why this pacing? What the heck is this? We're workshopping this, all right?
I'm gonna give some real examples of people who pre -submitted their channels for these things, which by the way, if you want to get in on the live, probably more roasty version of this that is coming this Thursday, then go ahead and join the group. It is radicalyt .com forward slash howdy, and you'll be able to get in. And if you're just now arriving, I want to know where you are in the world as well as the most recent thing that you ate.
So go ahead and put that in the chat. Why now? Tools.
And I think the real answer here is not just tools, but the capability to produce just got a lot, I guess, the barrier.
So if we say like barrier to entry for content is probably the lowest it has ever been in the history of online content right now. And so I use this as an example. I think tools is just one example of this.
It's the familiarity is there, the resources are there and the audience awareness of content. and the ability to make content is way lower. So barrier is much lower.
So things like, I just list this as ideas, things like ideas, outlining, creating visuals, editing on content and videos. And I'd actually love to hear from you, but this is why I put this down here, chat. What's a recent find that has changed your workflow the most?
I'm going to be talking more about this in the next live. One of the things I found recently that's been great, but I'd love to hear in the chat, have you found any tools or functionalities or workflow things or anything in the process of producing content that has changed your workflow the most or made making content a lot easier for you?
I'm just curious.
Hello, hello, Wisconsin Scrambled Eggs, Indianapolis. Awesome. London, Malaysia, from the Netherlands, right?
Thumbnail editor. Love that. So go ahead and keep putting your answers.
I'm genuinely curious what you have been finding recently that has been impact for you. Eric said, man, almost missed this. What's going on?
I'm talking about what the heck is happening right now and YouTube's next play. All right. So tools.
The barrier to entry just got a lot lower, but it's also easier for everyone. So I am seeing, and this, I watched real time as this happened with other online content like blogs or things like that.
Because the barrier to entry into content is a lot lower, it's easier for everyone. And it's a pro and a con. It's a positive thing for people like you and I, because it means many of the things that were previously, I'd say many of the things that were previously a barrier, like tech and process and things like that are a lot less prevalent.
But also because that's much lower, the ability to mass produce content and the AI slop and all that stuff is like, it can't be ignored. YouTube has done some stuff on it. Personally, I think, potentially they could do more about it, but that's not what we're talking about right now.
It's more, what does that mean? With the barrier for making content being so much lower right now, what does that actually mean for you and I as creators? And I think this is my absolute take on it right now.
This is why I was talking about live streams in my most recent. content and stuff, talking about how, it's like it's flipped back. It was, for the longest time, it was, well, it started out very raw, like content on YouTube was very raw, like, hey, let's just make videos because we want to make videos.
Got a lot more professional, a lot more polished. And now with the production of these tools and the barrier being so low to entry, the barrier right now is this.
Originality. Can you make original content and content that an audience enjoys? It's that.
It's as simple as that. Can you be authentic and all that?
Oh, yes, yes. Welcome to the new people arriving. Yes, if you're just now arriving, I'd love to hear where you are in the world and what you most recent thing you ate.
For me, it was eggs and toast. So I think I had some eggs and toast and yogurt and granola, something like that. So there you go.
Yes. Okay. So a few sources for this.
Flip side right now. It's so funny, guys. It's gone like full circle.
It started really raw content, super polished. And the super polished stuff is not going to go away. But my premise is for people who are not churning out content mill slop content.
It's going flipped back to authentic original content. This is genuinely what I'm seeing right now. So when I say this is YouTube's next play, this is what I'm talking about.
So a few sources, YouTube partner program policies, not to be mass produced, generic, repetitive, or manipulative. And then the letter for this year from the YouTube CEO, AI will remain a tool for expression, not a replacement. Things like that.
Another thing I'm seeing is... adaptations. I think it's a constant adaptation.
I haven't seen any major shifts in the YouTube algorithm, but more and more because the volume of content on this platform is so high, every viewer lives in their own, what I'm calling like a mini YouTube. So if you think of all the content on YouTube, what one viewer sees might be dramatically different than what another viewer sees.
So because of that, the attractiveness of creating content that is memorable, which I would put over here, original and proven.
Memorable.
The algorithm's getting better and better at showing people what they already like. So here's the premise for this coming year and going into our strategy going forward. Original plus proven equals memorable.
Here we go. Let's do this.
So here's the premise. Since this season, I'm calling it one proven thing, one new thing. It gives focus.
Here's the idea behind it. And if you got the email, if you're part of the creators group, I gave a little bit more context on this. If you're not yet part of the creators group and or you want to be a candidate for the roasting that occurs on the next live stream this Thursday, join the group.
It's radicalyt .com forward slash howdy. And you will be able to be in the group there. Yes, yes.
Love the messages coming in here. I'm just checking in here. Just now joining, watching a two -time speed from the start.
I'm from South Florida. Welcome, welcome. All right, all right, right.
Okay, some questions coming in. I think that'd be a good thing for maybe at the end. I've got a couple of, some time at the end for questions.
Colorado.
Yes, chai tea and oatmeal cookie. Awesome. Awesome, awesome.
Okay, so let's talk about this concept of your one proven thing.
When I say proven thing with your channel, it's with your audience. Specifically, it's a thing that is proven to do well with your audience, that your audience... already enjoys.
I'll double down on this as the source of truth here. When you find something or if you have something that your audience already enjoys with your content, it is an excellent time to double down on it. To re -emphasize you as an original memorable creator.
So when you think of your own channel, I want you to be thinking of your own channel or channels or content. Measure what you're doing with your audience on three things.
Generally, it beats your other videos. Generally, like it's something that either it's a concept that when you publish a video like this video, like a speed Lego builds for adults or budget Lego builds for adults or something like that. When you publish that type of video, it outperforms the other videos on your channel.
So that's one thing. And it does so usually fairly predictably. usually fairly predictably or consistently.
Another thing, a possibility is if people keep asking for it, meaning you get a notable amount of your fans or your audience that say, bring back such and such, or when are you going to do another such and such? With a key caveat here being. That oftentimes there can be a vocal minority, both for the positive or the negative, that are a point of data.
There's something to pay attention to, but they're not necessarily something to decide all of the fate of your content from. Because the silent majority, what people, the silent larger amount of people actually watch is a stronger indicator. But this is also one to keep in mind.
Yeah, yeah. Morning. Rebecca says, morning, Nate.
Welcome, Ohio. Okay, JC, awesome.
Yes, yes, yes. Awesome, welcome everybody, glad you're here. Okay, another one is if a few videos clearly stand out.
Videos you've done in the past that you haven't done repeats of, or you're thinking, hey, you know what? I haven't actually expanded on this more. That might also be a candidate for the new thing, which we're gonna talk about here in a moment.
But when we're talking about a proven thing that we're doubling down on right now, Typically, it's one of these three things. So thought exercise right now.
My proven thing is, and I know it's that because, put it in the chat. Even if you have no idea or if this is the first time you're ever thinking these thoughts in this order, my proven content thing is this with my audience. And I know it's that because of this, or I think it's that because of this.
Go ahead and put in the chat with the content you have right now. And it's okay if you don't feel super certain on it. I wanna see in the chat what you feel like might be this for you.
And again, if you're part of the group, I pre -sent out. Pretty extensive kind of context and email about this with a form essentially walking, well, it was a simpler version, but it was walking through how to figure these things out. So if you're not part of the group yet, I highly recommend it.
It's pretty awesome. So I'm gonna hear in the chat just from you, when you see this, your proven thing with your audience, like the content that is proven that somewhat at least fits one or two or three of these three things, what would you say that is? I want to see.
I'm very curious what that is.
Here we go. Houston texting. What's good?
Scrambled eggs. Okay, I'm just catching up on everybody. Scotland.
Beans on toast. Meh.
Oh, here we go. New episodes of my animations. It doesn't help me because it takes nine months to do one.
It's not sustainable. Jeff Santos, 93, says that.
Here we go. Best recommendation for a variety -based channel. Let's actually, yeah, yeah, bring that back up.
JC Prevails, bring that back up at the end. I've got, I'm going to do a kind of a more in -depth Q &A for that kind of thing. And then if you're just now arriving.
While you're answering this, I would love to keep answering this question. My proof of thing is, and I know because, and if you're watching the replay of this, by the way, put it in the chat, or the chat, the comments. Put it in the comments, because I do want to hear what your reaction is, what your gut reaction is at this point in the video, because I'm going to explain a bit more of it.
We're going to workshop this here in a moment, but I just want to get the wheels turning, so to speak.
Okay, let's see. Proven content thing. There we go.
Content that primarily bring views from other sources than YouTube. Okay, okay. Oh, interesting.
For example, Google search or embeds on external websites. Interesting. Eric Sillin says that.
Stands out, okay. Alexandria says, Alexandria says, proven content thing is workout creator reviews because I review a lot of them and spend the time with them so people don't have to. Ooh, ooh, love that.
Short video tutorials. Okay. Martin Goldman says that.
Millennium X has real -time 45 to 60 -minute videos decluttering and talking through decision -making. I know it works because those long videos get the most views.
Mortgage rate negotiation content. Okay. Okay.
The other Andy Hall says, Hi, Nate and all. I can't join, but I'll be back for the replay. All right.
Don't forget to boop the like button. Thanks, Andy. Don't forget to boop the like button.
It was Andy said it. I didn't say it. I didn't say that.
You can boop the like button on live stream, I think. And if you're watching the replay. Oh, this is awesome.
Keep it coming in. Keep it coming in. I'm looking for even more.
This is why we're intentionally gave as much context as I did before I ask you this, because I want the ideas flowing as we go into this next section. Okay, we ready? Let's move into this next section.
Workshop. we're gonna look at a real channel. This is someone that submitted their channel and we're gonna workshop it, all right?
Question I'm gonna be asking you as we look at this live together is which video type shows hints of a proven thing? And I wanna hear it in chat. Like when you look at this channel, obviously we're not gonna take the time to like watch through a lot of videos, but when you look at this channel, what hints do you see?
of things that are proven with the audience, like things that the audience seem to enjoy on a fairly consistent basis. All right, so here's the channel we're looking at. John Lewis Sports.
Are you here live, John?
Are you here live? If you're not, that's okay. You're watching the replay, but this is what we're looking at.
Actually, I'm gonna swap myself over to the corner so we can see this a bit more. The Word Nerd says, you can boop the like button during lives. I just always forget to ask.
Well, I actually forgot to ask until Andy brought it up. So Rebecca says, booping now, a laughing face. Yes.
All right. So we're looking at this channel. Remember the question we're looking to answer is, what are some hints at a proven thing?
the thing that the audience seems to enjoy, fairly predictable. So I'm just going to scroll through this, speak some stuff out. But I want you, even if you're watching the replay, I'm going to attempt to go ahead and put in the comments, or if you hear live, put in the chat, the hints or the things that you're seeing.
I'm going to attempt to speak out loud what's going through my mind as I'm looking for a proven thing. Okay, so here we go. We've got sports content, right?
Whatever happened to these alt football championship coaches? This QB has yet to play an NFL game. He belongs in the Hall of Fame.
We've got some recent sports content. How the UFL's best team destroyed the league. Then we've got this one.
This is interesting. How did this man get drafted sixth overall with no college football? Can you see this?
I think it should be right below me right here. 38K views two months ago. which there's a wide variety of views we're seeing thus far on this channel.
38K views, huh? Interesting. Interesting.
Wait, wait. ThePoorMan'sJoeNemath, 41K views. Oh, interesting.
Interesting. We're seeing some interesting standout pieces of content. There's some modern or recent stuff and some that seem to pull out older concepts, okay?
So as we're looking at this, what's coming to mind? When we look at this, I realize this is your first time seeing it for most people watching this, unless you're John Lewis Sports yourself. And then this is like your 10 millionth time seeing this.
And so to have it here roasted live is kind of fun. But I'm curious what you're seeing here. Now...
we've got a wide variety of fluctuation of views that I think is heavily related to the applicability of the topic of the video. But what if if I were looking at this, I would say, okay, a proven thing, even if it's not the one proven thing. There's some pretty interesting indicators here, which actually let me see if I can pull up.
This is Oh, here we go. When he submitted his channel here, this is what he said.
The four whatever happened to videos have a combined pre -YouTube view count change views of 120 ,000. So whatever happened to certain player, whatever happened to et cetera, we can actually see that.
Let's see if it shows up here.
Well, yeah, like this. Whatever happened to this? So when I see something like this, I think, you know, we've got some fairly positive indicators here.
All we need to do to identify this thread here, this proven thread, is to say, huh, there's a pattern there. There's something that might be worth doubling down on, which is the concept that we're talking about with this. Yeah, yeah.
When we say, hey, that's an example of this, that's what it looks like, okay? I am very certain that there are patterns or threads or proven things with your current channel, no matter how small it is or how large it is, that you have not yet clearly identified for what they are. Ah, so the challenge here is to double -check your content.
Go through this process. We're going to workshop another channel here, but double -check your content. Say, hey, hmm, there might be something to this concept.
Maybe I can double down on that. And there's some overlap with this. All right, let's look at another one here.
Workshop signals.
Oh, I'm still in drawing mode. This should be... All right, this channel did a fairly notable shift from camping videos to life off -grid.
So notable in that there's some overlap, some testing here. But I'm curious, as we're working through this, what signals tell you what is proven with your audience? Like what kinds of things do you think you would see?
is a proven concept or a thing that your audience seems to enjoy on a consistent basis. I'm going to look at this channel. Y 'all can see this, by the way.
I'm just double checking. I've realized I'm sharing my screen here and making sure that y 'all can... It shows up for me.
Can you see the channel Alaskan Nomads on your screen right now? Is that a yes? Yeah, yeah.
Okay, okay. I'm just checking in on the chat here.
There we go. Oh, Nameth, a football god.
Okay, okay, I pronounced it wrong. Yes, Nameth. Okay, thank you.
Appreciate you doing live and supporting creators. Yes, okay, yes. Okay, everybody can see it.
Good, good. I'm glad you can hear that. All right, so this one is very interesting because look at this.
Look at this. I'm gonna show you this. This is so interesting.
Which by the way, Alaskan Nomads, are you here live? They've been talking, like asking for me to look at their channel for a while. And if you're not here live, so help me.
I'm going to be so upset. If you're not here live, you better be here live. Because if you're not, we're going to be nice anyway.
We're going to be nice anyway. Okay, so a lot of camping stuff, right? And we've had some, there was some fairly good success with this camping stuff.
But something happened that shifted the proven thing fairly notably.
Here we go. Here we go. And they actually mentioned this in their submission when they submitted their channel here.
Off -grid cabin. We cleared a site for off -grid cabin in Alaska. By the way, that's a freaking good thumbnail.
Oh my gosh. Look at how good this thumbnail is right here. Just the use of the empty space and the pink square.
Beautiful. Chef's kiss. That was really good.
But it was interesting because what they shared, let me actually look at this. These are the ones I curated. There was more submissions here, but these are the ones I curated.
So they said their proven thing here was transitioning. Here, let me go ahead and switch over here. Transitioning from our camping content to documenting our off -grid journey while maintaining our authentic humor and leaving the little mistakes we make.
in the final video. So this is kind of towing the line between a proven thing and a new thing, which we're going to cover here in a moment, because we're talking about one thing, one thing season here. One proven thing, one new thing, which is what I'm encouraging pretty much all creators to take as a focus for this season, the next three or so plus months.
So off -grid videos. So in the original questionnaire, I ask, okay, what do you think your proven thing is? And what makes you say that?
Like, why? What did you say? And they said, our off -grid videos outperform our camping content almost every time.
So that is backed up by this channel with some of the recent things like this one. I quit my job of 10 years to live off -grid in Alaska. Almost a million views on that one two weeks ago.
Crushing it. Good job. This concept, really good concept.
We found a proven concept and we've... combined it really well with a new concept, which I will get back to here in a bit, right?
Okay, okay. Oh, okay, okay. Alaska is like three or four hours ahead.
I think being that early gives them a pass. Okay, okay. All right, we'll give them a pass.
You know, I'm just having fun with this, you know? Oh, they say they're probably building a snow fortress, though. Don't be upset.
Yes. Yes, I know. I'm just poking fun at them.
You know that. Okay. All right.
Let's get back to this. Let me go back to this. Okay.
So signals, right? Which I think brings us on to part two here. Your one new thing.
So we've got proven thing. We're saying, actually, let me go back here so I don't distract too much. Proven thing.
is something that shows clearly that you're seeing signals, however small, do well with your already existing audience. They're already proven. That's the key thing.
It's already proven to do well with your audience. If I were to use an example from, let's say, my channel, I would say things about mistakes that are uncommon. So that would be an example.
of a type of content where I go, you know what? A bunch of other creators in my space keep telling everybody to do these certain things. They're not working.
Or I see a lot of creators do these certain things. And even my clients have done these certain things in the past. It just, I've never seen it work.
It just does not work. So stop wasting your time on it. That's an example of a proven thing concept.
And I think, so I think when we, when you look at your own content and as we look at these, this part one, your one proven thing, I'm pretty sure you have at least an inkling of what a proven thing could be for you. Pretty sure. Pretty sure.
Yes. Yes.
Okay. Oh, Wind Walker Homestead throwing down in the chat here. Really?
They get a pass? I'm in the same time zone. Oh, throwing down.
Alaskan nomads, I don't know. Wind Walker Homestead just threw down with you. So I'm just saying maybe you don't get a pass because they're up.
I don't know. uh barky dog says he may be off grid uh howling sphinx just just put a a uh fire emoji yes i'm just saying i'm just saying maybe you don't get a pass after all of that and then you don't show up i don't know all that asking i don't know that might be a problem there all right part two your one new thing let's talk about this uh i want to know well actually i don't want to know this because i'm going to explain this first A good new thing.
So concept, take a proven thing, double down on it. What? Something that's already working well with your audience.
Now, here's where the originality and claiming new space and memorability with your audience comes in. A new thing. So a good new thing passes two checks here.
One, you're excited about it. Like you genuinely want to try it. If your primary reason for trying a new thing is just because you think your audience would enjoy it and you haven't actually paused to check and say, hey, do I actually like this or not?
That could be a problem. And then the second thing is it has a real shot with your audience.
So there's all sorts of stuff going on in the chat here. The laughing faces, oh, and Windwalker Homestead, and I wouldn't blame you if you were still asleep. I get it.
Oh, sorry, that was the word nerd that said that. Okay. So the second aspect of a new thing, when you're picking a new thing to add, a new type of content, a new concept to add to your content for your audience, it has to have a real shot with your audience.
Now, what do I mean by that? You have to have a reasonable amount of certainty that this new thing you're going to test is going to do well, either because you might have tested or done something like it with your audience in the past and maybe only did it once or twice and you're like, oh, that actually did fairly well.
Maybe I'll try that out. Or you see other channels trying or doing a similar concept to what you're considering, and they have a similar audience to yours, and you look at that and you go, okay, yeah, that might actually work for me. It's a pretty good indicator.
Yes. So where good new thing ideas come from, a signal from your audience, comments, requests, a format they love, things that they want you to try out, or if they have adjacent ideas like, hey, maybe you should try this certain thing. Or like I mentioned, proof from a similar creator.
It already works for their audience. So if you look at another creator that has a very similar audience to yourself and they seem to have a proven concept that you haven't adopted on your... channel.
Of course, you're going to adapt it to your own audience and your own style and make it original. But when you take a concept, let's say homesteading, since we're picking on off -grid homesteading right now, let's say it's that, and you see another creator in your space has had a lot of success with how to deal with, or let's say wildlife adventures around their homestead, where they're going and they're trying to, they've heard, hey, I've I'm going to go on an adventure and I'm going to try to find a mountain lion this time.
Or maybe I shouldn't condone this. I'm realizing that. Maybe I shouldn't.
I'm making this up on the spot. Don't try to find and be safe, okay? But let's say they have a concept where they're like, hey, let's make it safer, okay?
Maybe not predator animals. They're finding certain plants around their homestead, okay? Let's do that one.
Like poison ivy. Oh, geez. Yeah, let's say they're hunting around for plants in their area, right?
And they do these episodes where they're like, hey, I've got like 105 plants around my area and I'm making these videos and I'm trying to document finding each of them. I don't know. And they go on little mini adventures.
I'm making this up on the spot. Okay, okay. Let's say that's the thing, right?
You see that and you go, hmm, maybe I could adapt that. for my own audience. Maybe I could try out a thing, or maybe I could even do a collab with this channel where I say I'm going to start trying this angle and adapt it to my own audience.
So that's an example of that. That was a long -winded way of saying that. And somehow we got talking about mountain lions and poison ivy, so I was not expecting that.
Okay, a keynote here. A keynote here is a new thing. Is it...
There's workflows, there's tools, there's things like that. But in this context, a new thing equals something your audience will experience. So when we talk about one proven thing, one new thing, the whole concept of this, it's referring to for your audience.
So specifically content. Yes, we can try new things on workflow or a new tool and all that. And I think we should always be testing those out.
I always am. In this context, or in this framework, a new thing is something your audience will experience. Yeah?
All right. Let's workshop. Workshop time.
Oh, I know. I know this person is here, or at least they were. Okay, so proven thing is long real -time decluttering videos, talking and talking through every decision.
Here we got Millennial Meg. I think I've seen you in the chat. Are you here?
Is it a good one? I know we've talked about this channel previously, but it was just such a good example of what I'm explaining with this.
Yes.
And as part of that, I want to know, let's say you're the owner of this channel. Let's group workshop. This is why we're doing this here.
And again, be nice. Be nice, okay? But let's say you have this channel.
Meg's in the chat. Yay. I want to know from you, what would you try next on this channel?
Like if we're talking about a new content thing that we would try on this channel, what would you try next? If you had this channel, what are some things you might try? And I realize, again, this is, it's first exposure to this and all that, but that's okay.
Let's just, let's play. Let's practice here. So here's a channel, Millennial Meg.
Meg, sorry, Millennial Meg. So we're doing a variety of videos. Decluttering hasn't fixed my biggest budget problem and just made it more obvious, which by the way, I love that concept.
Awesome.
Ooh, I bought clothes for a life I don't live. You see that? That's right below me here.
I need to make sure not to cover that up in the footage here. Or I thought I was done decluttering the space. Or I gave my daughter too much junk.
The millennial mom made a video about me, so I took her advice. Wow, nice. So when you look at these, what are some concepts for new, like adjacent concepts or things that come to mind that potentially, let's put yourselves in the shoes of this channel.
If you were to make this channel, if you were in charge of this channel, what ideas come to mind of like, hey, what if we tried this new thing? Because we're talking in the context of... of new things.
Because proven thing, which we already, I did a little bit of a switcheroo here. So I apologize, Meg. I did a little switcheroo here where we're talking about both right now, and then we're going to do a bit more roasting in the next one.
But I think it's worth the context of combining proven plus new here. So this declutter exposed my worst habit. That one did pretty dang good.
Look at that. That's awesome.
All right.
Okay, okay.
Ideas coming in here. Specific places, maybe? Like decluttering the closet, the attic, the garage.
Okay, yeah. What to do with decluttering stuff? Charity, sell it, bin it.
Reacting to Marie Kondo tips. Man, I haven't thought about Marie Kondo in forever. That was really big back in the day, wasn't it?
I realize that under the clutter, I need to do some renovations, simple DIY renovation of hallway, closet, et cetera. Taking advices from family members. Ooh, these are some very interesting ideas.
Yeah. The reveal I wanted to show you here is, and this isn't, this actually isn't for a roast. It's more a real life example of this process of choosing a new thing in action.
Like this is a real life example of that.
So, Millennial Meg put in the submission, if I can get to it.
We had it. We had it somewhere. But, oh, it's somewhere.
I lost it. But the model is after some example adjacent creators. So if we pull these up.
This is it in action. This is the exact concept that I was just talking about in this previous slide here. This one right here with the proof from a similar creator that it already works with their audience.
This is exactly what I'm talking about. So Meg is looking at right here.
Things you regret buying. So these are example adjacent creators or Your home doesn't need more bins.
It needs stations. 20 ways to get organized. Or if this one pulls up, why I got rid of all my stuff.
So when we're talking about decluttering and adjacent ideas, testing a new concept that is adjacent to these three things that Meg shared, I think is a perfect example of this concept in action. So Meg, you're getting an anti -roast. Your thinking is very spot on.
Like this is awesome. Yes, very good. Spot on, spot on here.
Excellent, more ideas coming in here. What to do with toys the kids don't play with anymore. Here we go.
How to make money in decluttering. Yeah, see, these are all like excellent adjacent ideas for we take a proven channel, we take things and we say, okay, let's test adding additional content types. And there's another reason.
for this concept of your new thing, because with it, one of the things that I will say sometimes privately, I don't say a lot publicly, but there's a constant state of, what would I say? What's the word? Attrition?
I think that's the word, attrition. Audience attrition just happens naturally for most creators, unless the creator is continuously. So attrition being gradual decline or fall off or a reduction of audience numbers.
So with this, the reason why I'm saying proven thing is double down on something that's already working. You've got a good baseline. You've got a good solid foundation.
And then we take a new thing, we add it on, and we can do this as many times as you want to test out additional angles and to counteract audience attrition.
It works really well. It works exceptionally well. Yes, attrition.
Yes, yes. Good, I'm just checking on the chat here. Yes, good.
Excellent ideas coming in here. Yes, good. Oh, actually, I'm gonna cover this right here because it's Jeremy Forever said, those videos don't appear to be outliers though.
Does that matter? If the concept is one that fits your goals as a, because you want well -performing videos for adjacent channels, similar creators, right? You want well -performing videos.
Whoa, I wanted to actually draw. You want well -performing videos, yes. But sometimes what you're looking for is a consistently performing type of video.
not just an outlier type of video, which is a very good thing you brought up because if you like a consistently performing thing for your audience and you want to add another type of format that is fairly predictable and consistent with your audience, even if it doesn't always outperform, oftentimes it can be very worth adding to your docket here, right?
Yeah. Yes. All right.
So here's the idea. Put them together. The best new things feed the proven thing.
I think you already get this by this point, but I'm just going to reiterate it here. All right.
Your best new thing takes what you've already proven with your audience. You've already tested something with your audience. And the new things, if it performs well, it feeds the proven things.
So then the new thing becomes it naturally. meshes with your existing audience or proven things uh and then you carry on carry on yeah yes good uh good good questions here so with the uh alexandria says uh what about when a concept is proven but difficult to sustain ah then it doesn't necessarily fit you does it if you've proven something, but you, maybe it's proven with your audience, but it's not something that you can sustain yourself.
I don't know if that classifies as a proven thing. Well, it does technically classify as a proven thing with your audience, but it's not proven for you. Like it's not sustainable long -term.
I was having a conversation recently with a client about similar thing as this, where essentially I'm going to switch back to main cam for dramatic effect here. You ready?
Let's get it. Switch back. Did it switch back?
It did. Okay. I was talking with a client recently where we had a very similar conversation to that question that you just asked, where she was essentially realizing that a certain type of video did perform well with the audience and it performed well consistently.
Like we're talking 100 to 300K views consistently on this long form type of video.
the conversation had to come up of, but is this actually sustainable? Does this, the approach, the current way that we're doing things, is that actually sustainable? And I think we came down to, okay, we have to go one of two directions.
We either have to, we can keep doing this as we're currently doing it and be okay with publishing less often because of the amount of work that went into this type of content, or We can try another angle, which in this case might be a new thing angle. I'm going to go back to showing my screen here.
In this case, it might be a new thing angle where we try lower effort types of content that still feed into that proven. Maybe we keep doing the proven. We just continue it at a lower, slower pacing once a month or something.
But we try new angles, new types of content that feed into that audience.
Yes. Very good things. Good questions.
Good concepts here.
Faith on the Water says, I'm the faith -based niche and would love to get your deep dive take on faith -based content and mental health. I think that's a good concept. Let's bring that back up at the end when we do the Q &A at the end.
That's a good question. Rebecca has some good points. I need to know more about Meg's audience before giving a suggestion.
That's great. Follow -up questions. What stage of life are they in?
What are they trying to accomplish? Yes.
Okay, okay. Ooh, do you think, Howling Sphinx says, do you think it's worth doing unsustainable formats for visibility before transitioning smaller? Zoe, it's a good question because having, I'm addressing this because it's on topic with what we're talking about right here.
Having, doing occasional things that bring in new audience, it can be a double -edged sword. Because if it brings a new audience, it gets more viral appeal, it spreads to more people, that's great, but it's unsustainable.
That's the add -on, right? It's unsustainable for you as a creator. So we brought in a bunch of new audience, we got some awareness, but if that audience came for that thing that's unsustainable and you can't actually continue doing it, So you flip them to other types of content.
You run the risk of maybe not appealing to that new audience that you brought in. It's one of those things that's like, to get a bunch of data all at once, if you have a pretty good idea, like to give a good signal to the algorithm, hey, a lot of people like this, it can be good. But if you have a pretty good idea of proven things that are sustainable that would also work for that audience, then yes, it could work.
Yeah. Yes.
Yes, that's good. Good point.
Okay, all right. I want to make sure we have time for the Q &A here. So I'm actually going to add one more workshop.
I'm going to do more workshopping on Thursday, by the way. Which, by the way, if you're just now arriving here, if you're watching this replay, I'm going to highly recommend that you join the group. I'm sending out another email this week sometime, today or tomorrow.
or maybe that, yeah, today or tomorrow, as of recording this or doing this live, join the group, radicalyt .com forward slash howdy. I'm going to send out a form for you to submit your own things. And I'm going to be doing a especially roasty format of reviewing these things.
Because the idea is saying, first of all, what is my proven thing? And if I can get my eyeballs on what you're sharing as your proven thing and I go, okay, yeah, you're actually, you're right. You're good on that.
Or maybe it's not that. Maybe it's actually this, right? Or, and then the new thing you say, okay, so my proven thing is this.
My new thing is this. And I say, okay, that new thing might run into issues because of X, Y, Z. That's the point.
That's what we're going to be doing on Thursday this week for one thing, one thing season kickoff week. So that's happening this week. Join the group if you want to be a candidate for that.
I'm going to skip over. I had another workshop thing because I wanted to get to the Q &A here. Make sure we have the time.
to cover that. So actually, wow, I just already covered this. Wow, I'm ahead of myself here.
Next, get your channel roasted. I mean, reviewed live. So do this first.
Join the group. Here's the link. Just go to this website and share your proven thing, share your new thing, right?
We're gonna be covering a lot more of this on Thursday. Principles applied, how I'm doing it myself, and then as well as your channel's roasted live. We're gonna be doing that.
Again, the goal here is, to see are you on the right track like are we on the right track and to even if your channel is not roasted or your answers aren't roasted to be able to see other creators um in action like the like yes this is the right track this is a proven thing this kind of thing is going to be a thing to double down with your audience this is an original thing and uh this kind of thing is a good adjacent thing and i would love to on thursday if we get a lot of examples of proven plus new things as adjacent concepts that we're pulling together.
This is it. This is it. Yes.
Oh, the word nerd said, I feel like I need to resubmit my new thing now because I have a better idea. Go ahead. You're welcome to actually.
If you already submitted, because I know a lot of people already submitted for this first thing, that's still included in the pool for Thursday for roasting, even if I didn't get a chance to cover it right here. Today, I wanted to show some examples in action of the concepts I was showing. And then Thursday, we're going to be roasting the heck out of stuff.
Just roasting, toasty. Pull out the s'mores, and we're going to toast some marshmallows on the roast, right? But with that, so yeah, the word nerd, if you already submitted, something then you yes you can submit again or if you if you have a better idea now after watching this one just put like in all caps at the beginning of your answer like hey this is the new one ignore the old one or something like that so i know um yes yes yes okay uh rebecca velar says velar says uh there's value in seeing others roasted i mean reviewed yes uh world wheelchair warriors yeah yeah because i need help lol And then Matt says, why not?
Hmm, s'mores. Yes, please. Yes, please.
Also, I'm having a bit of fun with this because I'm going to be revealing a fairly notable large announcement about my content on Thursday. Yes, I'm playing up the drama a bit because I have fun with playing up the drama. But yes, that's what I'm saying here with, so I'm going to be sharing organic audience growth.
I'm doubling down on that and the proven thing. I have right here my big reveal. Yeah, my new thing, I'm announcing it on Thursday.
I'm playing up the drama. You will get not only the roasting and the real more examples of this in action, but you will get a bit of the behind the scenes and the concepts and how I'm approaching the new thing for the new season. As well as, I don't want to spoil too much.
It is going to be awesome on Thursday. So, yes. Yes.
Faith on the Water says, what time Thursday? Same time as this live stream started. It's funny because I was trying to figure out when to do live streams.
Guys, I ask you where you're from in the world. We got people all over the world. Freaking global audience here, which is awesome.
But picking a time when everybody can be there live is nigh on impossible. It basically is. Unless our dear friends in New Zealand.
I think it's like, what is it? Like two in the morning right now over there? Yeah.
Like there's nothing. Not to mention like Iceland. I'm just kidding.
I'm just making stuff up. But that's why we're doing this. I might try other times in the future.
But yes, yes.
Windwalker Home said, perfect. I started working on something new at the start of summer. Might have to submit it.
I want to see it. I want to see it. I really want to see it from you.
Barky Dog says, roasting and drama? It's like the Iron Chef up in here.
Oh, Lewis Worth says, it's 22 hours 58 in Malaysia. Yep. Yep.
Wow. Oh, okay. Hey, Sweden, it's four in the afternoon.
Well, you're living large. I thought it was early for me. It started at like, because I'm in mountain time and it's like seven when it started.
And I was like, oh, it's too early. So anyway, all right, it's live. It's question time.
But also let's admire for a moment this. You're going to be seeing a lot more of this going forward. One proven thing, one new thing season.
It's time, guys. If you want to focus or if you're not sure what to do right now, if you're not sure what to do this season, take this. Take this as a focus.
Double down on a proven thing with your audience. Something, however small, that you already have data. This is accomplishing so many things all at once.
A proven thing is something that works for you, something that works for your audience, and it's something, because of that, the algorithms are following that and they're saying, yeah, this is working. Great, I have data already. I have enough to be able to fairly predictably predict whether a new type of this type of content is gonna do well.
You're double downing on that. It's accomplishing all of these goals all at once. And also if there's another goal, it's monetization, right?
Sponsorships, partnerships. So you can, it's easier to sell something or to do an affiliate deal or things like that when you're able to go to them and say, hey, look, see, I wanna feature you in this type of video. And they go, oh yeah.
Yeah, that performs pretty consistently. Companies like to see that. So it's like a quadruple win.
So if you want to focus, that's first part. One proven thing. And the new thing is counteracting the audience attrition, keeping you fresh as a creator, and continuing to train the algorithm and your audience, though you're not training your audience.
That sounded bad. But continuing to... show additional original concepts which is the concept we talked about at the very beginning um with the full freaking the freaking full circle thing of um with with lower tier content if you're just now arriving here this this is it uh lower tier where is it lower tier content being easier to make the crazy thing is the barrier now is originality making something that is memorable for your audience.
So that's what we're doing. So when I say you're going to be seeing a lot more of this one proven thing, one new thing, that's what I'm talking about, guys. If you want a focus, if it's helpful to you to say, with my content this season, this is what I'm going to focus on.
One proven thing and one new thing. There you go. Yes.
All right, now we're getting on to...
Questions. We're going to wrap it up with a note. This, if you're watching the replay of this and you want to see questions live, I encourage you to stay on.
And let's see what's, let's see what's going on here. So all the things that I ever, all the things that I've covered thus far, or the things that I said, Hey, bring that back at the end. Now's the time to bring back those questions that I said earlier at the beginning.
All right. What do you got? What do you got?
Oh, Steve Cassidy Guitar says, Nate, did you ever weigh in on the new YouTube view count changes from first frame back in August? I think you're referring to the engaged versus the new view metric. This is the part where I say, you know, I'm actually going to go back to main cam.
I'll write stuff down if I want to. Yeah.
But with the... New YouTube view count changes. It is what it is.
I mean, YouTube made that choice.
It is what it is. I thought about weighing in on it. I don't know that I can make like a full video about it.
But I think the short version is, yes, it's, YouTube decided to do that just to, I think to delineate numbers. in some ways, is artificially inflating numbers, in my opinion. But it's a choice.
It's a choice. So you can still see engaged views. You just have to click a few times to see it.
Yes.
Yes. All right. Mockstar Game says, howdy, howdy, Nate.
Welcome. Howdy, howdy. How are you doing?
All right. Let's get these questions here. Mad Ventures, are collab videos really bringing in more subs?
I've done some extensive testing on that, or I should say extensive but limited because I would like to do more testing on that. And I think as far as a way to directly put your videos in front of other people, yes, it is working in front of a new audience, an adjacent audience, ideally a collab video. I'm talking about the collab being a direct, like, hey.
Two channels directly say, yes, we are collabing together, right? The concept of doing that has been around on YouTube since essentially the beginning, right? As ways to say, hey, we're friends.
Go check out each other's channels. It works. I think this is just formalizing it from an actual YouTube standpoint.
It seems to do some stuff. The main thing I'd say is when you do a collab like that, be as awesome as you can. Just be fun, be engaging, be who you are.
And it makes it much more likely for people to say, wow, I haven't heard of this person before. This is cool. I like to, you know, I want to see more of what they're doing.
And I think in that way, yes, it does. As far as like a magic bullet or what's a silver bullet to magically get you more subs? No, but yeah.
Yes.
Steve Cassidy says, yes, engage views versus BS views.
Okay.
Let's see. Have I noticed it's harder to get subscribers these days or is it just me? It's a mix, right?
So that because of concepts I was talking about at the beginning, there's a lot of mass produced content. The barrier to entry is much lower and therefore a lot more content means a lot more competition. So this is why I'm emphasizing one proven thing, one new thing here.
So yes.
Okay.
What do you do when you're in a niche that the typical advice doesn't really translate to? Well, that depends on the niche, doesn't it? I mean, what niche?
Are you referring to the booktube niche? Is that what we're referring to? Yes.
Okay, okay. Advice, variety -based channels centered on faith, family, and gaming. I do debates, gaming, teaching, and reaction videos.
So, all right. So variety, oh yes, I remember your question about variety -based. Here's the thing.
Every channel needs to have, and I'll say this will come up fairly often. This isn't an immediate, I want you to know this. It's not an immediate shutdown of variety -based.
content. It's that there is a struggle that a single concept that when understood makes variety based channels possible. But when it doesn't, if it's not understood or it's not applied or it's not like it's not working on the channel, it's variety based channels are always going to have struggles.
You have to have You have to have common threads. And it can't just, the common threads can't just be like you liking the thing unless you're intentionally taking a personality approach with your content.
Like meaning people come and hang out with you. If you're familiar with my like four creator types, there's hero, commentator, teacher, and performer. If you're taking the hero approach where you're the one having the experience and you're the personnel and you're bringing people along for the journey, then you can have a variety of different experiences.
Like I tried such and such. or I did this food, or I did this gaming, or oh my goodness, this game is crazy. If you take that approach, then yes, it can work.
But a lot of times with variety channels, the approach taken is in one of the other types where it's like a commentator, for example. I am talking about gaming. What was the example you say?
Right now, I'm talking about my family. Then I'm gonna talk about a game. Then I'm gonna talk about my faith.
If you're talking about a lot of those things and you're taking the wrong creator type or the wrong approach, It's always going to have a hard time because from the audience perspective, they're being thrown all over the place. They have to have common things that when they think of your channel, they think, I like that channel because, and it can apply to at least 90 % of the content on your channel, even if you have random one -off videos.
That's what I mean when I talk about common threads. That's what has to be present. So if I were in your shoes, I'd be saying, all right, what are the common threads?
And if I can't clearly identify them or if it's not playing out with my audience, like if I make a gaming video and it gets lots of views and I do a debate video and it gets no views, that's a sign that there aren't common threads. Like when you get that spiking, you're too topic -based and not common thread -based. Is that cool?
Well, I'm hoping that's helpful here. Yes.
Okay, let's see, let's see. What do we got here?
What's a good length for videos? Mountain Woman Paradox. What's a good length for videos?
I have 4K subs and good retention, but I'm about to lose early access YPP due to watch time dropping. Videos are 2 to 10 minutes long. That's a fairly large range to be between 2 to 10 minutes long.
Probably a... It depends on the video. What does your audience want?
What's the intention of your audience? And... Based on that, like if they're here to like learn something and they want it to be like a big guide, then a longer video, like a 15, 20 minute video or even longer can be a good one.
If they're here for an adventure, generally, unless you're like a highly produced adventure type of channel, generally, they're looking at about 10 minutes. A range, when you get into like the two, up to six minutes is kind of a weird range. I made a video about this.
You should watch this. I think it's called, I found out which video length makes videos explode or something. Just search on my channel.
I found out which video length and then it will show up. That'll answer it. Good.
Because there's a lot of nuance to choosing video length.
All right. Let's see. DreamingFree88 says, what do you think about doing holiday freaking content?
Like a series that's 12 videos over the season. Double -edged sword. I'll just say that.
Can be extremely good, but then what happens after the holiday is over? If you've built a thread, speaking of common threads, if you've built a thread that is seasonal or has an expiration date over here, what happens once the expiration date occurs? If you haven't built, this happens a lot on gaming channels where they'll do like a let's play and they'll have like a 10 episode series playing through a certain game.
If they become too known for a certain game, what happens when that ends? fall off, right? Drop off.
So a lot of the smart ones is they'll take a seasonal thing like what you're saying or like a, let's say it's the holiday of Christmas, right? Let's say it's that. We're planning to do an episodic series of that.
That's great. But if it's the only thing you do for a month straight or two months straight, then you're going to have a notable drop off afterwards. So I always recommend that you include other threads or other proven things.
in your mix as you're doing that. So it's not a no, it's just, it can actually be very good. Like it can have a lot of engagement because of the seasonality of it, just like a trend.
But make sure that's not your only thread for an extended period of time. That's good. That's good.
Great question.
Here we go. Here we go. Ooh, ooh, can I ask about, okay, so there's been a lot of, there's a lot of chat about the engaged versus BS views.
I want to know from you, if you've ever, if you've looked at your analytics, because I have access to a lot of channels when I'm doing like audits or with my clients and stuff. But so I've seen some trends as far as engaged versus the new views metric. What are you seeing?
Because Barky Dog is saying about 50 % difference between real and fake views for me. So 1200 is 600, 500 is 250, et cetera. What are you seeing?
When you look at the average engaged, new views metric versus engaged view, what's the difference there? Because I would love to hear that.
This is me asking a crowd poll for everyone here live. Or if you're watching this replay, I genuinely would like to know, put it in the comments. What are you seeing?
Because this is me saying, okay, what is the average across here? Because then we can more clearly say, hey, yeah, this is the new thing. So whatever views you're seeing on YouTube, just take half of it off or something like that, right?
That's what I'd like to do.
Okay, all right. You're putting that in the chat here.
I'm just looking at the questions here as you're putting that in the chat here. Okay, here to do it.
Rebecca Villar says, relaunched my channel about a month ago, was publishing every week. Now I can only do twice a week. I'm assuming you mean twice a month.
How long before YouTube finds my audience? At the moment, making videos 1 % better each time. Often it just takes a concept.
I think, Rebecca, when we're talking about this, it sounds like if YouTube hasn't found your audience yet, we don't have a proven thing yet. So right now we're essentially trying new thing, new thing, new thing. So what I would do if I was in that situation, is this.
Let me scroll over to here. New thing. You're essentially taking this until you find proven things, right?
So take things you're excited to make as a real shot with your audience. So even if we don't have a lot of signals with your audience, existing audience right now, what we're going to do is a lot of paying attention to Similar creators or audiences that have the type of content that you want, what are they doing?
And you're adapting that to your own audience and your own spin, your own take on it. So yes.
Yes.
Chemistry in a nutshell says, speaking of attrition, any advice for a gaming channel that, for a channel that a lot of people stop watching when their college chemistry classes end? That's a good one. Chemistry in a nutshell.
So you do chemistry stuff with college chemistry classes. Yeah, we've messaged back and forth and stuff. So with that, part of it is there is a hard stop on that, right?
So in this case, there's a few things we could do, right? So for anybody here, if you're watching this, have you ever been in a mode of life where you... really wanted to accomplish something, let's say it was a class or you're trying to fix your car or whatever it is, and you watch a whole bunch of videos about something and then you just don't care afterwards, that's a fairly common thing, right?
So it's not like we're gonna try to change human psychology in that case, but potentially what we could do there is say, is there a reasonable next step or an adjacent thing that they would want? So it's possible, chemistry in a nutshell, it's possible we take the approach of, I mean, it's possible in entirely another channel that's like the lifetime learning channel or something like that, where you take similar things, but now you're speaking to people that want to stick around.
They want to stay on. It's kind of, that one's kind of a big stretch, but I'd be thinking that direction where I go, okay, so humans. When they're done with it, like students, when they're done with their class, most of them are just not going to keep watching these because they're trying to pass a class, right?
So if that's the primary intent, what other adjacent things do they want? Do they want to continue their education? Do they want to be a lifelong learner or things like that?
Or do they like your personality and your take on a variety of topics, not just chemistry? So that would be the case for another channel, like a personality channel or something like that. That was a really good one.
That's a good one. I think that's one to continue exploring.
Yes.
Here we go. Okay. Here we go.
Okay. Okay.
Here we go. The word nerd said I just watched that video. Oh, okay.
We were referring to the video length video. I found out which video length. So if you have more questions on that, watch that on the channel.
Well, let's see. I'm actually curious about these ratios here that people are putting in the chats. What do we got?
I'm finding the chat threads here. Here we go. Okay.
45 to 55%. Same. It's 50 % for me.
45 -ish. 30%. 50 -50.
Almost exactly 50. Engaged is about 40%. Less, 55 to 60 % engaged views.
I'm gonna jot this down. So we've got a range, it seems like, of, what's this? Actually, this is like a 30 to 60 % range.
Okay, with the new views changed, that's very interesting. I wanted to ask you this because I was seeing similar patterns. I was seeing roughly 45 % being like a rule of thumb.
So that's very interesting to know. Yes, that's very good. Eric, man took a call and missed most of the live.
Well, I'm glad you're here. I'm glad you're here though. Yes.
All right. Well, let's make sure we didn't... Miss anything here?
Yes, yes.
This chat, I swear it's hard to scroll sometimes in here. Make sure I got everything.
Here we go, here we go, here we go. Okay, 62 -year -old gamer. So this is IronWolf007.
62 -year -old gamer, mostly survival game content, thinking of pivoting any suggestions. So I think that kind of depends a lot on the approach you've been taking. Generally...
If the current approach isn't working with gaming content, most of the time you see gaming channels do well in one of two categories. And I realize this is a broad generalization, but... But this is what I've seen over and over again.
One category is personality gamers, where they become basically like an influencer or a celebrity where they're the thing and they can play a variety of different games. They're just very entertaining as they're playing games. Some people do a lot of rage.
Some people do calm games. I saw a channel the other day that was like... fall asleep while I play XYZ game.
I had never seen that before. I was like, what the heck? It was like an hour and a half or two hour long video.
I was like, okay, all right. And it was working. It was working.
So personality gamers or style gamers. So people who really like survival games or horror games or things like that. In both cases, the key with gaming is to not be forgettable, is to be entertaining.
Because the differentiation with gaming creators is not the game, it's the creator. And that actually applies to a lot of niches, but that's really the case with gaming creators. It's, you gotta be entertaining.
So that's what I would be doing with that.
All right, all right. Yes, yes, okay, okay, good. Get that with my Halloween and Christmas stuff.
Always drop off after the holiday passes. Okay, so accurate. We're accurate.
You guys are doing awesome. All right, I think we're going to call it there. Thursday, we're going to do another one.
We're going to freaking crush it. I'm just reminding you this. If you're here live and you haven't yet joined the group, join the group ASAP.
If you're watching the replay and you haven't yet joined the group, join the group ASAP. I'm sending out another message because we're doing this. We're going to take these principles that we talked about today, apply it.
I'm going to talk a bit more in depth on how I'm applying it myself, as well as maybe some clients channels and stuff. And then your channels, I'm going to be roasting them and your responses live, as well as my big reveal on what my new thing is. I'm playing up the drama here.
We're going to have fun with this. You guys are awesome. Thank you for showing up.
Whatever time of day it is, middle of the night, morning, afternoon, I'm glad you're here. Thank you. I appreciate you taking the time.
We're going to call it there. Thank you, everybody. You're amazing.
Keep up the good work. And also let me know if you ever want a fireside chat with digital s'mores where we talk about mental health. We talk about that side of things.
Like I really would like to know if you ever want to do something like that. I think it'd be fun.
Yeah, you guys are awesome. We're going to end it there. Thank you, everybody.
Cheers. Cheers, everybody. We're signing off.
The Hook

The bait, then the rug-pull.

The title promises YouTube's next play, and the answer arrives about twelve minutes in: when anyone can produce polished content with AI tools, the platform swings back toward what can't be mass produced. The rest of the stream turns that into a simple season plan, one proven thing plus one new thing, and tests it live on three submitted channels.

Frameworks

Named ideas worth stealing.

04:23model

One Proven Thing, One New Thing

  1. Double down on one proven thing with your existing audience
  2. Add one new thing you're excited about that has a real shot
  3. Make the new thing feed the proven thing

A season-long focus: anchor the channel on what already works and keep testing one adjacent format to stay fresh and offset attrition.

Steal forquarterly content planning for any channel or newsletter
13:56concept

Original + Proven = Memorable

With production barriers gone and every viewer in a personalized feed, memorability comes from combining an original take with a format your audience already responds to.

Steal forpositioning content in an AI-saturated niche
15:41list

3 signs it's proven

  1. It beats your other videos
  2. People keep asking for it
  3. A few videos clearly stand out

Signals that a format already works with your audience, weighting what the silent majority watches over what a vocal minority says.

Steal forauditing a back catalog
33:54list

A good new thing passes 2 checks

  1. You're excited to make it
  2. It has a real shot with your audience

Ideas come from a signal from your audience (comments, requests, a format they love) or proof from a similar creator whose audience already responds to it.

Steal forvetting new format ideas
1:05:04list

Four creator types

  1. Hero
  2. Commentator
  3. Teacher
  4. Performer

The hero type, where the creator has the experience and brings viewers along, is the one that can carry a variety channel.

Steal fordiagnosing why a variety channel struggles
CTA Breakdown

How they asked for the click.

VERBAL ASK
51:00link
“Join the group. Here's the link. Just go to this website and share your proven thing, share your new thing.”

Repeated at least five times across the stream and tied to a concrete reward: submit by Wednesday to be a candidate for Thursday's live channel review plus a teased 'big reveal'.

Storyboard

Visual structure at a glance.

live open
hooklive open00:00
season title
promiseseason title04:29
easier for everyone
valueeasier for everyone11:28
mini YouTube
valuemini YouTube13:28
Part 1: proven thing
valuePart 1: proven thing15:28
sports channel workshop
valuesports channel workshop23:27
off-grid workshop
valueoff-grid workshop30:34
Part 2: new thing
valuePart 2: new thing35:25
adjacent creator proof
valueadjacent creator proof42:54
put them together
valueput them together46:24
Thursday roast pitch
ctaThursday roast pitch53:23
common threads Q&A
valuecommon threads Q&A1:05:21
Frame Gallery

Visual moments.

One-click upgrade to your Google

Get more breakdowns in your search results

Add Modern Creator as a preferred source and Google shows you more of our breakdowns in Search, Top Stories, and AI Overviews. It only changes what you see, and you can undo it in your Google settings anytime.

Add to Preferred SourcesOpens your Google source preferences with us pre-loaded. Tick the box and you're done.
Watch next

More from this channel + related breakdowns.