A 20-year YouTube veteran who walked away from a 500K-subscriber channel explains the exact competitor-mapping system she uses to find an unclaimed gap in a crowded niche.
Posted
yesterday
Duration
Format
Tutorial
educational
Views
420
25 likes
57 · 43
Big Idea
The argument in one line.
Standing out in a saturated YouTube niche comes from systematically mapping every competitor in the space and hunting for the one specific gap nobody is filling, not from trying to out-produce everyone else on the same ideas.
Who This Is For
Read if. Skip if.
READ IF YOU ARE…
You're starting a YouTube channel in a niche that already feels crowded and you don't know where you'd fit.
You're a small or mid-size creator who wants a repeatable system for tracking competitors instead of guessing.
You're stuck between picking a topic too broad to stand out in and one too narrow to find an audience in.
SKIP IF…
You already have a clearly defined niche and audience and just want tactical thumbnail or title advice.
You're looking for paid-ads or algorithm-hacking growth tactics rather than positioning strategy.
TL;DR
The full version, fast.
Standing out in a crowded niche starts with research, not creativity: subscribe to every channel in the space (or use a tool that automates it), log each one's views, vibe, and sub-genre in a database, then look for what everyone is saying and ask what nobody is saying. Next, Goldilocks the niche so the topic stays broad but the target person stays narrow, since standing out is really about who you're speaking to, not what you cover. Gaps come from circling repeated patterns, reading comments for unanswered questions, holding a contrarian belief, pairing an expected format with an unexpected setting, or crashing two unrelated interests together. Once a gap is found, the creator makes herself hard to copy with an on-camera goal, a documented personal history, or small signature choices only she has.
Free for members
Chat with this breakdown — free.
Sign in and you get 23 free chat messages on us — ask for the hook, quote a framework, find the exact transcript moment, generate a markdown action plan. Bring your own key when you want unlimited.
Cold open: every niche looks saturated, but the creator just did it again from a brand-new channel.
00:22 – 01:24
02 · The alt account strategy
Make a fresh anonymous account, subscribe to everyone in the niche, and let the algorithm map the space; keep private playlists for titles, thumbnails, and ideas.
01:24 – 02:19
03 · Why competitor research matters
Build a spreadsheet of every competitor logging average views, vibe, and sub-genre, because you can't find a gap without first knowing the full landscape.
02:19 – 04:07
04 · The faster way to research competitors
Demo of the Velio tool building a tracked-channel database automatically, pulling 840+ travel channels and letting her add specific competitors and filter by views and uploads.
04:07 – 06:00
05 · Is your niche too broad or too narrow?
The Goldilocks test: a niche is the specific person you're happy to show up for, not a topic, so go broad on topic and narrow on person.
06:00 – 11:08
06 · Finding content gaps and mixing ideas
Four ways to find a gap: circle what's repeated and ask what's missing, hold a contrarian belief, pair the expected with the unexpected, and crash two unrelated worlds together; use a niche brainstorm map to combine personal interests.
11:08 – 14:55
07 · How to stand out and be uncopyable
Play a character built from who you really are, then make yourself hard to copy through starting-from-zero documentation, a public goal, leaning into your history and credentials, and small signature choices.
Atomic Insights
Lines worth screenshotting.
A niche isn't a topic, it's a specific person: the people you're happy to show up for and don't regret attracting.
You can't find what gap is available to you until you know exactly what's already out there.
Going broad on the topic but narrow on the person is what makes a channel stand out in a crowded space.
A database of competitor channels should mix small, medium, and large creators so outlier theory actually works.
Combining two unrelated interests (family travel plus healthy homes) produces angles neither niche covers alone.
A contrarian belief is simply a stance your niche holds that you quietly disagree with, turned into content.
Pairing an expected format with an unexpected setting, like doing makeup tutorials outdoors, is enough to differentiate without inventing a new category.
Nobody can copy a journey that started at zero, which makes documenting the start of a channel a durable form of originality.
Publicly committing to a long-term goal, like reaching 100 countries, gives viewers a reason to keep watching that a competitor can't replicate.
A channel's credibility history, like two decades on the platform, functions as a receipt that is genuinely hard for anyone else to produce.
Finding a real gap can take months or years inside a niche; it rarely shows up on the first pass through competitor research.
Takeaway
Standing out starts with mapping the niche, not avoiding it.
WHAT TO LEARN
A crowded niche isn't a reason to avoid it; it's raw material for finding the one gap nobody has filled, once you actually map who's in it.
01Why every niche feels crowded
Before judging a niche as too crowded, build a full map of who's actually in it; a subscribe-everything alt account or a free spreadsheet works as well as a paid tool.
02The alt account strategy
A fresh, anonymous account subscribed to every channel in a niche lets the algorithm itself reveal the full competitive landscape without bias from your existing watch history.
Keep separate private playlists for titles, thumbnails, and ideas while you research, so inspiration gets filed by the part of the video that sparked it.
03Why competitor research matters
Track average views, vibe, and sub-genre for every competitor so you have a high-level view of the space instead of a gut feeling about it.
You cannot find what gap is available to you until you know exactly what's already out there.
04The faster way to research competitors
A tracked-channel tool can replace weeks of manual subscribing and spreadsheet-building with filters by views, uploads, and suggested similar channels.
A database that mixes small, medium, and large channels teaches more than one of just the biggest players, because outlier theory needs a range to compare against.
05Is your niche too broad or too narrow?
Define your niche as a specific person you're glad to serve, not a topic, then keep the topic broad and the target person narrow.
Narrowing the audience to one concrete person, like a parent planning a family trip, makes it obvious which adjacent topics belong on the channel.
06Finding content gaps and mixing ideas
Circle the ideas that repeat across competitor videos, then ask directly what's missing and what nobody is saying; comments sections surface the unanswered questions.
State a contrarian belief, something your niche assumes that you don't buy, and build content around the disagreement.
Pair an expected format with an unexpected setting, like doing a familiar tutorial in an unusual location, to differentiate without inventing a new category.
Cross two unrelated personal interests to generate angles a single-topic competitor can't produce, then filter every idea through whether it still serves your one chosen audience.
07How to stand out and be uncopyable
Build a personal brainstorm map of your passions, skills, work history, and what you inherently know, so you have material to combine with your niche later.
Develop an on-camera persona by amplifying what you already are rather than inventing a performance; the goal is finding where you naturally shine, not acting.
Make yourself hard to copy by documenting the start of your journey from zero, publicly committing to a long-term goal, and leaning into your real history or credentials.
Expect finding a genuine gap to take real time, sometimes months or years inside a niche, rather than showing up on the first pass through research.
Glossary
Terms worth knowing.
Alt account strategy
Creating a fresh, anonymous YouTube account and subscribing to every channel in a target niche so the algorithm's recommendations reveal the full competitive landscape without bias from an existing viewing history.
Goldilocks niche
A niche sized so the topic is broad enough to generate ongoing content but the target viewer is narrow enough to be a specific, identifiable person.
Outlier theory
The practice of studying videos that wildly over- or under-performed relative to a channel's normal numbers to learn what actually drives results, which requires a competitor database that spans small, medium, and large channels.
Contrarian belief
A position that runs counter to what most creators and audiences in a niche currently accept as true, used as a content angle to differentiate a channel.
Niche brainstorm map
A worksheet that lists every passion, skill, piece of experience, and inherent knowledge a creator has, used to find adjacent angles that can combine with a chosen niche.
“A niche is the people you like talking to, the people you are happy to show up for.”
reframes 'niche' as a person, quotable definition→ newsletter pull-quote↗ Tweet quote
10:29
“You don't want to have this fake persona. What you're really trying to do is figure out where you shine as a person and then just double down on that.”
“I've been on YouTube for almost 20 years. That is a very hard set of receipts to copy.”
credibility flex that doubles as the episode's thesis on being uncopyable→ TikTok hook↗ Tweet quote
The Script
Word for word.
Read-along
Don't just watch it. Burn it in.
See every word as it's spoken — crank it to 2× and still catch all of it. The same dual-channel trick behind Amazon's Kindle + Audible.
17px
metaphor
These days, it feels like every niche on YouTube is too crowded. So if you're brand new or if you're a smaller creator, how do you ever break out? Well, I just did.
Six months ago, I started this channel from scratch and I'm already out viewing channels five times its size. And I've done it before. I was one of the first travel vloggers ever.
And when that got crowded, I found another gap. So here's the exact method I use to find those gaps. This is called my alt account strategy where you are going to make a fresh account.
I mean, it works best if it's fresh, but just subscribe to everybody in your niche. I want you to watch so many videos that you fall so far down the rabbit hole. That YouTube's like...
I think that this girl likes fantasy books. And while you are doing that, I want you to make a few private playlists. I like one for titles, one for thumbnails, and one for ideas.
You can also add one for formats if you want. Anytime a video inspires you, I want you to save it to the according playlist. Then we're gonna take those channels that you subscribe to and build out a database in Google Sheets.
And for each one, I want you to make sure that you're writing down their average views for a video, their vibe, and their sub -niche or genre that the channel falls in. And this is so we could have a high level overview of what this niche is actually looking like. In case you're sitting there going like, oh yeah, this step takes time.
Yeah, it takes time, but it is such an important one. And so many people never do it. Like in a brand new niche, how do you know what your competitors are?
I mean, you all want to start a YouTube channel, but how do you know what is currently out there and where do I fit in? How can I fit in? And what gaps can I create?
You cannot find what gaps are available to you if you don't know what's actually out there in the first place. Because you can learn a ton of information by seeing what's working. You can see what are people actually clicking on.
So you can ask, what is everybody saying about this topic? And think of what is nobody saying? Now that is how I used to spy on my competitors, but I have done it the tedious way long enough, and now there are actually easier ways to do this.
So now I use a tool called Velio. You can do everything that I am about to show you using an alt account and spreadsheets. You can do it all manually for free, but I just use Velio because...
I just don't have time. It's just easier and I don't have time. Let's do some example databases.
First, we are going to create a new channel database. Let's let it find the channels for me. Travel vlogging channels.
I don't want travel vlogging channels. I want to be a travel vlogger. Let's add me and then let's add my friends, Kara and Nate, since they are killing it in the travel space.
Let's see what it comes up with. It found 840 channels. Now I can rank it by views.
I can rank it by total amount of uploads. There's all sorts of stats. I have this huge competitor database that I can pull from now.
And if I wanted to add more channels, so say it missed, let's see if it missed some of my friends. More suggested channels are popping up on the side here where it's like, okay, if I want to check them out, I could click there. It takes me right to their YouTube.
Now this channel actually has 475 subscribers. i'm still going to track them you want to build a database that's kind of like a mixture of smaller medium and large creators because you can learn a lot from all of them by using outlier theory now i have 857 channels that i am tracking in this travel blogging niche you know what i'm also really passionate about air quality i literally have an air sensor on my desk We don't need to digress into that, but interesting.
So for this database that I built in this niche, I only found 24 channels. That is significantly smaller than the 840 I found with just travel. So now you're going to start organizing your databases, tidy up your channel list.
And if a channel doesn't actually fit in your niche, you can just delete it. Then you're to start categorizing videos like we did manually with our playlist, where you group ideas into folders based on what part of the video inspires you. Next, we need to Goldilocks our niche, which is making sure we're not going too broad or too narrow.
So to do this, I want us to take a step back and think, what? actually is a niche this is my friend roberta blake's definition which i thought was really good so i'm just gonna read you it a niche is the people you like talking to the people you are happy to show up for it's a narrowing of your focus to the people that you can serve and don't regret attracting and i love his definition because he's not viewing a niche as a topic but a specific person because really standing out a niche is just standing out to the people looking for those videos we want to make sure we're going broad on our topics but narrow on our person and this is how we're going to stand out who am i speaking to in the travel niche well if i choose family travel the person that i am talking to is a parent planning a trip for their family that is the that is my niche and all the topics that go around it can expand on and build out my channel and obviously my air purifiers which my house is a little too small so what if i instead expanded it to healthy homes because that person would probably be also interested like if they care about the air they're breathing they probably also care about the materials that they're used in their house there's so much that that specific person could also care about and look now i have 51
channels i have a much larger database of channels to pull from the more you refine your database the more channels you add the more uh specific to your niche you can the better the information that you're gonna get but when you're trying to figure out what to do this is a great way to like research what your niche actually looks like now that we have an idea of who our person is we've got some competitor research the database is built up how do we stand out to them in 2010 when i first started traveling was blogging at the time travel blogs were huge that was what you do and i realized that i hated writing i much prefer to tell the stories and showcase my experiences by vlogging it and that worked for a while until everybody started vlogging and then in 2016 i found another gap i started making travel advice videos educational content about travel on youtube and nobody was doing that at the time and those blew up because i'd found a gap having being able to see what everyone else is doing is going to allow you to do this a lot easier and i want you to kind of like circle things that are that kind of come up repeatedly and then i want you to ask the real question what are they not doing what is missing from these databases i also want you to go into those videos and start reading the comments and just kind of like seeing like what are questions that are popping up that people are asking coming up with the gap is the hardest part and sometimes it might only be like
one or two gaps that you find and that's it and you can base your whole channel on that and it could succeed and you can be the breakout channel just based on those couple gaps so this is from caleb rolston he's like a big personal branding guru but he is big on contrarian beliefs and which is basically a belief that you hold that is the opposite of what people in your niche hold so what do people in your niche say or believe that rubs you the wrong way is there anything that like you're like, no, I don't really believe in that.
I don't trust that. My example is back in 2014, a lot of the like solo travel advice was all like very much pro, you can do anything and everything by yourself. Here's how to do it all by yourself.
So my contrarian take was that solo travel didn't have to be solo at all. You can do a group tour the entire trip. So you're never by yourself, but that is still solo travel because you still took that trip.
Alone the next thing you could do is you want to pair the expected with the unexpected So a really good example. This is there's a beauty creator called. I think it's Louisa Powell pew She is doing makeup tutorials outside in stunning locations, right?
This is the same makeup tutorials that have been done a million times. There are so many beauty and makeup creators But she does them outside. She's just pairing the expected which is a typical makeup routine with the unexpected so the next way that we can do it is by crashing two worlds together the best angles can come from two different things that you can put together well we're doing family travel and air purifying our healthy homes oh we're traveling to the greenest houses in america the cleanest houses in america something to always ask your airbnb or verbal before your booking to make sure you're keeping your family safe how to plan your trips so you're avoiding wildfire season i mean these are literally just things i've just came up with the top of my head but i'm combining those two worlds that i live in so even though i might have already i only picked one niche so say my niche is family travel that's the niche i want to be in i can actually use any other databases any other parts that make up me and help build out those ideas those concepts that is why i want you to do
your niche brainstorm map these are all the various things that can make up you and that you can have a niche in on your channel now you only are going to pick one but you can use any other aspects to help combine and create these unique perspectives and angles that only you can cover. As long as the channel itself appeals to the person that you are trying to target.
This is the matchmaking, mish -mashing, the coming up with the most unique thing that you can and make it fun. Like this should be fun. You should be having a creative...
enjoying experience from doing this next is you want to kind of play a character built from who you actually really are because a mistake that i see a lot of beginner creators is they they're trying to find this like youtube persona and that's not what i mean by this you don't want to have this like fake person that you're trying to be on camera what you're really trying to do is figure out where you shine as a person and what style really suits you and then just double down on that hone in on that and let that become your persona.
I am not an artsy filmmaker. I am not a motivational speaker. I do not have a company where I've had thousands of students that have gone through all of my classes because I have a guru teaching class.
I don't have that. You're figuring out what you're not and then just amplifying what you currently are and making that the character of you. And if you don't know what makes you you and how to kind of do that well that's a whole other video that's this is basically what personal branding is and that's a that's a beast of a topic so we will leave that at that the last thing you have to do is you have to make yourself hard to copy because as soon as you start blowing up people are going to copy you i know it's happened to me nobody can actually copy a journey that starts at zero and what i mean by this is like how many house reno videos are on youtube thousands but nobody has done your house this is really great for diy learning tutorial any sort of those types of channels and this is again what helps build out the actual video itself right because we've been talking a lot about packaging and now we're talking more about like the context of the stuff that you're actually creating, the videos itself.
Another way that you can do this is by committing to a goal. So my friends Kara and Nate for a while had a hundred country goal. They were trying to reach a hundred countries.
They had this on their banner and at the beginning of their videos, they would say what country they're on. You were going through these countries together. You're on this bigger journey that no one else could replicate because no one else is going to be on country number 75 and it'd be the same country as karen eight's country number 75 and they've said that this was a huge part of the growth of their channel and really getting people to subscribe and want to watch more because you as a creator being committed to something that's really hard for someone else to copy the next is your credibility but through a new lens so this is like your results your histories your credibility and if you do my niche brainstorming exercise which again you should all do because this will help you build out the rest of your uniqueness you will find these credibilities you will find these these little stories in you there's a reason i say that i've been on youtube for almost 20 years a lot in my videos that is a very hard set of receipts to copy not many people can say that it is a very unique defining feature of me
And by being uncopyable, it makes you naturally stand out because no one else is going to be able to replicate that. So you need to find that version for your own channel. Something that only you can say, that only you have.
There are just so many little things that all add up that will help you stand out when you're editing, when you're creating your videos, when you're presenting yourself on camera and how you do that and how you package it. Every single one is an opportunity to be unique. and is an opportunity to be different so when i was doing this channel and i was looking at my databases i instantly noticed that dark moody black thumbnails were very popular in this niche my thumbnails look nothing like all the thumbnails in this niche like there i am i crafted my thumbnails differently one other way i could stand out in this niche i'm not saying that this is easy this is actually very difficult to do it takes a lot of brain power creative thinking to come up with these gaps, to find these gaps.
And it might not be visible to you right away. Like it might actually take you many months, many years of being in a niche to be able to see these gaps. Another reason why building these databases, whether that's on YouTube, by just subscribing to a bunch of these channels that are in your niche, your competitor channels, or by using Velio or by just using a Google spreadsheet, however you do it.
Building these databases will serve you for the entirety of your creator journey. But you could see why I use Velio instead. Like what took me weeks with an alt account just takes me literally minutes.
Now, if you do want to give Velio a try for yourself, I'm going to leave an affiliate link down below so you can check it out and go find your gap and have fun with it. And once you have found your gap, you need to keep making videos consistently. And how do you do that when life gets in the way?
Well, you lean on one of my seven easy video formats.
The Hook
The bait, then the rug-pull.
Every niche on YouTube looks taken. The creator argues it isn't: six months after restarting a channel from zero, she's already outviewing channels five times its size, using the same competitor-mapping method that let her find a gap twice before in twenty years on the platform.
Frameworks
Named ideas worth stealing.
06:04list
Four ways to find a gap
Ask what's missing / what's being said
Hold a contrarian belief
Pair the expected with the unexpected
Crash two unrelated worlds together
A checklist for spotting an unclaimed angle once a competitor database exists: look for repeated patterns and ask what nobody is saying, state a belief that runs against the niche consensus, combine a familiar format with an unexpected setting, or merge two of your own unrelated interests.
Steal forany positioning exercise for a new offer or content pillar, not just YouTube
11:23list
Make yourself hard to copy
Document starting the journey from zero
Commit to a goal on camera
Lean into your results, history, or credentials
Small things that add up
Four ways to build durable differentiation that a copycat can't replicate because they missed the starting point, the public commitment, or the years of history behind it.
Steal forany personal-brand positioning where competitors can copy the content format but not the track record
09:22model
Niche brainstorm map
Passions
Skills and experience
Work and business
Things you inherently know
Things you want to learn
Obstacles you've overcome
A worksheet of everything that makes up a person, used to find secondary angles that can combine with the one chosen niche to create a unique perspective.
Steal forcross-pollinating a niche content calendar with personal angles nobody else in the space can cover
CTA Breakdown
How they asked for the click.
VERBAL ASK
14:23product
“If you do want to give Velio a try for yourself, I'm going to leave an affiliate link down below.”
Soft affiliate pitch placed after the tool is already demonstrated and shown delivering value, rather than upfront.
Add Modern Creator as a preferred source and Google shows you more of our breakdowns in Search, Top Stories, and AI Overviews. It only changes what you see, and you can undo it in your Google settings anytime.
Add to Preferred SourcesOpens your Google source preferences with us pre-loaded. Tick the box and you're done.
One creator's five-video series about climbing Mount Kilimanjaro pulled in more lifetime views, subscribers, and watch hours than her one-off uploads ever did, and the analytics show exactly why.